Forced and ambient vibration testing of full scale bridges
Authors: Piotr Omenzetter, University of Aberdeen, UK; Sherif Beskhyroun, Faisal Shabbir, Ge-Wei Chen; Xinghua Chen, Shengzhe Wang, Alex Zha, University of Auckland
Paper number: 383 (EQC 13/U578)
Abstract
Knowledge about the performance of structural systems, such as bridges, can be created using laboratory-scale experimentation, analytical and numerical simulations, and full-scale, in-situ experimentation on existing structures. The latter method has several advantages as it is free from many assumptions, omissions and simplifications inherently present in the former two. For example, soil-structure interaction, non-structural components, and nonlinearities in stiffness and energy dissipation are always present in their true form in full-scale, in-situ testing. Thus, full-scale experimentation results present the ground truth about structural performance. The performance evaluated this way is used for advanced assessment of the working condition of the structure, detection of the causes and effects of damage, aging and deterioration, evaluation of the quality of construction, checking of design assumptions, and also provides important lessons for future design and construction of similar structures.
In this research, four different bridges (a two-span cable-stayed pedestrian bridge, a two-span concrete motorway bridge, an 11-span post-tensioned concrete motorway off-ramp, and a major 12-span post-tensioned concrete motorway viaduct) were tested using environmental excitation (e.g. vehicular traffic) and/or forcing provided by shakers. Experimental data were analysed using techniques that were able to extract the resonant frequencies of the bridges, quantify vibration energy dissipation and visualise the shapes of bridge vibrations. The analyses of data collected in field experiments included observing how stiffness and energy dissipation change with the amplitude of forcing and response. Another way of gaining insights into the dynamics of the tested bridges was via detailed computer modelling of the structures. This enabled identification and understanding of the mechanisms responsible for their measured performance. Because the experimental results and numerical predictions always differ to a certain degree, novel methods for calibration, or updating, of structural models were investigated. These methods, based on mathematical metaphors describing of the behaviour of a swarm of bees or school of fish proved to be efficient tools for model calibration.
Technical Abstract
A great deal of knowledge about the performance of structural systems, such as bridges, can be created using full-scale, in-situ experimentation on existing structures. Full-scale testing offers several advantages as it is free from many assumptions and simplifications inherently present in laboratory experiments and numerical simulations. For example, soil-structure interaction, non-structural components, and nonlinearities in stiffness and energy dissipation are always present in their true form in full-scale, in-situ testing. Thus, full-scale experimentation results present the ground truth about structural performance and indeed provide the ultimate test for both actual constructed systems and laboratory and numerical investigations. The performance evaluated this way can be used for advanced assessment of structural condition, detection of damage, aging and deterioration, evaluation of the construction quality, validation of design assumptions, and also as lessons for future design and construction of similar structures.
In this research, four different bridges (a two-span cable-stayed pedestrian bridge, a two-span concrete motorway bridge, an 11-span post-tensioned concrete motorway off-ramp, and a major 12-span post-tensioned concrete motorway viaduct) were tested using ambient excitation (e.g. vehicular traffic) and/or forcing provided by shakers. Experimental data were analysed using multiple system identification techniques to extract the resonant frequencies, damping ratios and mode shapes. For the 12-span viaduct, these techniques were compared and recommendations were made for their use in future testing exercises. The analyses of experimental data included quantification of resonant frequency and damping ratio changes with the amplitude of forcing and response for the 11-span motorway off-ramp. The frequencies were found to decrease and damping ratios to initially increase and then stabilise, respectively, with increasing response amplitude. Detailed computer modelling of the structures was also undertaken and enabled identification and understanding of the mechanisms responsible for their measured performance. A novel optimisation method for updating of structural models was proposed and investigated. The method, particle swarm optimisation with sequential niche technique, belongs to global optimisation algorithms, mimics the behaviour of a swarm of bees or school of fish in search for the most fertile feeding location, systematically searches the updating parameter domain for multiple minima to discover the global one, and proved effective when applied to the experimental data from the pedestrian bridge tested in this study.
Order a research paper
Many of these research papers have PDF downloads available on the site.
If you'd like to access a paper that doesn't have a download, get in touch to ask for a copy.